.svg)
Getting a new roof isn’t just about fixing leaks. It’s one of the biggest upgrades you can make to protect your home and make it stand out. Most replacements return around 60 to 70 percent of what you spend when you sell, but the benefits go way beyond resale numbers. A solid roof boosts curb appeal, helps with energy costs, and gives you the confidence that your home is covered. Literally.
This guide walks you through what professional roofing services really bring to the table — from upfront costs to the payoff years down the line. Whether you’re switching out worn shingles, going for something tougher like metal, or replacing a roof that’s falling apart, we’ll break down which materials matter and how to get the most value from your investment.
The Real New Roof ROI: How Much Value Does a New Roof Add?
When it comes to roof replacement ROI, the numbers tell an encouraging story. According to the Cost vs. Value 2024 Report by JLC Online, roofing projects deliver competitive returns compared to other home improvements. While the average ROI varies by material (from approximately 48% for metal roofing to 57% for asphalt shingles), roof replacements generally outperform many popular home renovations.
To compare, a basic kitchen remodel with a nearly $80,000 price tag only gets back 49.5%. A high-end bathroom addition? That one tends to recover just 32.6% of its six-figure cost. So, if you're looking for an upgrade that doesn’t tank your wallet, roofing is often a smarter move.
Still, how much value your roof adds depends on a few real-world details:
- Geographic market conditions: Buyers in your area and the local housing scene shape what your roof is worth.
- Material quality and durability: Stronger, longer-lasting materials help bump up your home’s value.
- Installation expertise: A team that knows what they’re doing — and backs it up with a solid warranty — makes a big difference.
- Current roof condition: Swapping out a roof that’s in bad shape can lead to a higher return than replacing one that still has some life left.
Bottom line? A new roof might not return every dollar, but it pulls its weight. It helps your home look better, perform better, and sell more easily. That’s a smart upgrade with real staying power.
Types of Roofing Materials and Their Impact on Home Value
The roofing material you choose significantly influences both the cost of your project and its impact on home value. Here's how different options compare:
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are a trusted option for most homeowners. They’re familiar, dependable, and work well in a variety of home styles and climates. You can find them in a wide range of colors and profiles, which makes them an easy fit for boosting curb appeal.
They offer the best balance of cost and performance, with a cost for asphalt shingle roof installations typically ranging from $7,600 to $17,800 for a standard home. According to Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs. Value report, asphalt roof replacement delivers an ROI of 60.7% nationally, though this varies by region — in the Midwest, including Illinois, the ROI sits around 51.0%.
Metal Roofing
Metal roofs have seen a surge in popularity due to their exceptional longevity and energy efficiency benefits. This comes at a higher initial price point, typically $20,000-$44,000 for an average home. The ROI for metal roofing hovers around 48.1% nationally according to industry data, though in the Illinois data, it's slightly lower at 43.1%.
The higher initial investment often pays dividends through extended lifespan (40-70 years), significant energy savings (15-25% on cooling costs), superior weather resistance, and sustainability credentials. For eco-conscious buyers or those in severe weather regions, metal roofing's premium often translates to higher perceived value.
Cedar Shake Roofing
Cedar shake roofing offers distinctive charm that significantly enhances curb appeal, especially for architectural styles like Craftsman, Cape Cod, or rustic homes. According to data from Angi, cedar shake roofs typically provide an ROI between 50% and 70%.
Cedar's 30-40 year lifespan makes it an attractive middle ground between standard and premium materials. Its value varies based on cedar quality, local climate conditions, regional preferences, and architectural compatibility, though it requires more maintenance than synthetic alternatives.
Clay or Concrete Tile Roofing
Tile roofs bring a bold, distinctive look that's often seen on Mediterranean, Spanish, or southwestern-style homes. These materials typically last more than 50 years and cost between $22,000 and $45,000 on average, putting them in the premium category with an expected ROI of 45% to 55%.
This return can go even higher depending on where the home is located and how well the tile matches the surrounding architecture. In neighborhoods where tile is the norm, or on homes where design details really matter, it can play a big role in buyer interest. In hotter regions, the natural cooling benefits of tile only add to its appeal.
Slate Roofing
Natural slate offers unmatched longevity and timeless elegance with lifespans routinely exceeding 75-100 years. The substantial initial cost ($27,000-$68,000 for an average home) yields a modest ROI of 40-50% in most markets.
For luxury homes, historic properties, or any house where architectural detail matters, slate offers a sense of permanence and authenticity that’s hard to match. It appeals to buyers who value craftsmanship and longevity, and it can become a major selling point for the right type of home.
Your Roof’s Hidden Return on Investment
Beyond the straightforward resale value calculations, a new roof delivers additional financial benefits that aren't immediately apparent but contribute significantly to its true ROI.
Insurance Benefits of a New Roof
Many homeowners see lower premiums after replacing an old roof, especially when switching to more durable or impact-resistant materials. Most insurance companies offer discounts — often between 5% and 35% — for newer roofs, depending on the home’s location and risk profile. That means better coverage and long-term savings.
Energy Efficiency and Utility Savings
Modern roofing materials, particularly those with ENERGY STAR ratings, can dramatically reduce your heating and cooling costs through improved insulation and reflective properties. Homeowners typically save 7-15% on energy bills after installing a new roof with proper ventilation and insulation. Over a 20-year period, these savings can add up to $10,000 or more!
Tax Benefits and Incentives
Modern roofing materials, especially those designed with energy efficiency in mind, can dramatically reduce heating and cooling costs. Energy-efficient asphalt shingles with enhanced reflective properties can lower cooling expenses by 15-30% in summer months, while proper insulation and ventilation installed during roof replacement further improve year-round efficiency. Check the ENERGY STAR federal tax credits page for the most current information on available benefits.
Beyond ROI: How a New Roof Impacts Your Home's Marketability
Does a new roof help sell a house? Real estate professionals overwhelmingly agree: yes. While ROI matters, the impact on buyer interest, speed of sale, and negotiation power often adds even more value.
- First impression excellence: A new roof dramatically improves curb appeal, creating the positive first impression that often determines whether potential buyers even schedule a showing. Studies show that 92% of realtors believe curb appeal is their clients' most important exterior feature.
- Elimination of negotiation obstacles: When the roof is new or in great shape, it removes one of the most common reasons buyers ask for price cuts or repairs, often at a cost higher than the fix itself.
- Reduced market time: Homes with newer roofs tend to sell one to three weeks faster than similar listings with older roofing. That quicker sale helps avoid carrying costs and repeated price drops.
- Inspection protection: Roof problems are one of the most frequent deal-killers found during inspections. A newer roof lowers the chances of last-minute issues that delay or derail closing.
- Emotional confidence: Buyers feel better committing to a home when they know the roof won’t be a surprise expense. That peace of mind often leads to stronger, more confident offers.
When buyers are weighing their options, a new roof sends a clear signal that your home is well cared for and worth considering.
When Is It Worth Replacing Your Roof Before Selling?
Replacing your roof before listing your home isn’t always required, but in many cases, it gives you an edge. It depends on what shape your current roof is in and what your buyers expect.
Signs that roof replacement is worth the investment:
- Visible damage: Missing or curling shingles send a clear message to buyers that repairs are needed right away.
- Advanced age: If your existing roof has exceeded 80% of its expected material lifespan, replacement often makes more financial sense than roof repair.
- Structural concerns: Signs of sagging, water damage, or deck rot point to deeper issues that need full replacement.
- Failed home inspection: If a buyer walked away over roof concerns, it’s a sign that fixing the problem is the only way forward.
- Market expectations: In high-end areas, buyers usually expect move-in-ready homes. An old roof can push serious buyers away.
Delaying roof work often leads to much bigger problems. Leaks can damage insulation, wood framing, and electrical systems. Once moisture gets in, mold and structural damage follow quickly. And when buyers spot a roof problem, they tend to lower their offer, often by more than what the roof would have cost to replace.
Maximizing Your Roof's Value-Adding Potential
To get the best return from a roof replacement, every step — from planning to materials — needs to be intentional.
- Professional installation: Work with licensed, experienced contractors who offer reliable warranties and check every detail.
- Material selection: Use materials that fit your climate and home style. Buyers notice when the roof suits the property.
- Timing considerations: Avoid weather delays and ensure quality by scheduling during stable weather months.
- Energy upgrades: Add ventilation, insulation, and reflective materials to reduce future utility costs.
- Insurance certification: Get paperwork showing storm resistance or other premium-reducing features to share with buyers.
- Proactive inspections: A pre-listing roof inspection can uncover minor issues that are easier — and cheaper — to fix in advance.
Maximizing value doesn’t mean overspending. It means choosing smart, well-matched options that will pay off in your local market.
